Want to explore the NYC dating scene from a different lens? High-end dating websites and apps may be the answer. These platforms have carved out a niche for those seeking a more exclusive experience. Two names for this space, the Luxy dating app and EliteSingles, are often mentioned in the same breath when it comes to elite matchmaking. Both apps cater to selective singles, but they take very different approaches.
Luxy is frequently dubbed the “millionaire dating app,” emphasizing luxury lifestyles and affluent members, while EliteSingles focuses on highly educated professionals looking for serious relationships. Given New York City’s blend of ambitious career-driven folks and luxury enthusiasts, it’s no surprise these two apps are often compared. But which one actually delivers real matches for NYC singles?
In this guide, we’ll compare Luxy and EliteSingles head-to-head on features, safety, pricing, user base, real user feedback, and more. By the end, you’ll have a clear sense of which app might be the better fit for you, whether you’re seeking casual high-end fun, a serious soulmate, or just a partner who appreciates the finer things. Let’s dive in.
Luxy vs EliteSingles: Which is Right for Your High-End Dating Needs?
You’re diving into the world of dating apps, and you want to know which one—Luxy or EliteSingles—will actually deliver real matches. Both cater to specific crowds, but they’re not the same. Luxy is all about connecting wealthy, successful, and attractive singles, while EliteSingles targets educated professionals seeking long-term relationships. Let’s break it down to see which one fits your vibe.
Features
When you’re navigating the dating app landscape, finding one that delivers real, meaningful matches can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. Both Luxy and EliteSingles promise to connect you with like-minded singles, but they target different audiences and offer distinct experiences.
Luxy gives you a swipe-based, visually appealing experience with features like browsing nearby high-value singles, free messaging with matches, and sending virtual gifts. Premium options like Luxy BLACK add perks like seeing who liked your profile. EliteSingles, on the other hand, starts with a personality test and sends 3-7 daily matches, plus a “Have You Met?” feature for browsing. It also includes a relationship blog for dating tips. The features of each app shape how you interact and find potential partners, so let’s break it down.
- Luxy: The Luxy dating app leans into a swipe-based, visually driven experience, similar to what you might know from Tinder, but with a twist of exclusivity. You can swipe to like or pass, browse high-value singles nearby, message your matches for free, and even send virtual gifts to keep the conversation flowing. Premium subscriptions, like Luxy BLACK or PLATINUM, unlock extras such as seeing who liked your profile, advanced filters for more specific searches, and features like “FaceMe” for video chats. It’s all about efficiency and catering to those who value quality over quantity, with a focus on connecting with remarkable individuals
- EliteSingles: This app takes a more structured approach, starting with a detailed personality test that analyzes 29 traits to find compatible matches. Every day, you’ll receive 3-7 handpicked matches based on your test results, preferences, education, and location. There’s also a “Have You Met?” feature, which lets you swipe through additional profiles, and a “Wild Card” option for 20 extra daily matches to expand your horizons. The app includes a mobile version for on-the-go dating and a relationship blog packed with advice, from first-date etiquette to online conversation starters. It’s designed for busy professionals who want a hands-off, matchmaker-style experience.
| Feature | Luxy | EliteSingles |
| Matching Style | Swipe-based, browse nearby | Personality test, 3-7 daily matches |
| Communication | Free messaging with matches, virtual gifts | Message matches, “Smile,” icebreaker questions |
| Premium Perks | See who liked you, advanced filters, video chat | Additional profile views, “Have You Met?” feature |
| Additional Tools | None mentioned | Relationship blog with dating tips |
Luxy’s simplicity might appeal if you prefer a more visual, swipe-heavy approach, while EliteSingles’ structured matching could suit you if you value depth and guidance. However, Luxy’s premium features feel more tailored to its exclusive audience, giving it an edge for high-end users.
Related Reading: Top 7 NYC Dating Apps Compared: Features, Pricing & Success Rates
Safety: Protecting your profile
Online dating safety is non-negotiable, especially since you’re sharing personal details, and both apps have measures in place, but they prioritize different aspects.
- Luxy: Given its focus on high-profile users, Luxy invests heavily in safety. Profiles are verified in real-time to ensure authenticity, and new members must pass a vouching process where existing users approve them, requiring at least 50% approval. This helps maintain a high-quality, exclusive community, with income verification for wealthy members to match within similar economic brackets. It’s all about keeping the platform safe and fun for its affluent users
- EliteSingles: This app also takes safety seriously, with features like ID authentication, manual profile verification, SSL encryption to protect against credit card fraud, and a fraud detection system. They regularly screen for inactive users and employ methods to prevent harmful messages, such as alerting the site to certain keywords. However, some user reviews mention encountering fake profiles or mismatches, suggesting the system isn’t always foolproof
| Safety Feature | Luxy | EliteSingles |
| Profile Verification | SSL encryption, a fraud detection system | ID authentication, manual verification |
| Data Protection | Not explicitly mentioned | SSL encryption, fraud detection system |
| User Screening | Income verification, 50% approval | Regular screening for inactive users |
| Harm Prevention | Community-driven exclusivity | Keyword alerts for harmful messages |
Luxy’s verification and vouching process might give you more confidence in the authenticity of users, especially if you’re concerned about fake profiles. EliteSingles’ systems are robust, but they seem less tailored to an exclusive, high-income crowd.
Pricing: What you’ll pay
Dating apps aren’t free, and the cost can influence your decision. Let’s see how they stack up.
- Luxy: The basic version is free, letting you swipe and message matches, but to unlock premium features like seeing who liked you or using advanced filters, you’ll need to upgrade. Pricing starts at around $12.99 per month for Luxy BLACK, based on available descriptions, with higher tiers like PLATINUM offering more perks. Some users have mentioned paying $79.99 or $99.99 for a one-month Luxy Black account, suggesting prices can vary. It’s not cheap, but for its target audience, it’s seen as a worthwhile investment, with options for promo codes to reduce costs.
- EliteSingles: This app requires a premium subscription for full access, with prices at $75 for one month, $120 for three months, or $170 for six months. It’s pricier than Luxy, reflecting its focus on a broader professional audience. While it offers a free tier for browsing, you can’t message matches without paying, which might feel limiting if you’re testing the waters.
| Plan | Luxy (Starting at) | EliteSingles |
| Monthly | ~$12.99 (Luxy BLACK, varies) | $75 |
| 3 Months | Not explicitly stated | $120 ($40/month) |
| 6 Months | ~$300 mentioned by users | $170 ($28.33/month) |
| Free Tier | Basic swiping, messaging matches | Browsing, limited interaction |
Luxy’s lower entry point might appeal if you’re budget-conscious, while EliteSingles’ higher cost could feel justified if you value its structured matching. However, Luxy’s pricing feels more flexible for its affluent users.
Related Reading: Step-by-Step Guide to Crafting an Irresistible Dating Profile for NYC Singles
Userbase: Who you’ll meet
The people using these apps can make or break your experience, so let’s look at the demographics on these elite dating apps:
- Luxy: This app is unapologetically for the elite. Over 41% of users earn $1M+ annually, with 3.3% earning $750K+, 7.6% earning $500K+, and so on, down to 17.6% earning $250K+. It’s a playground for millionaires, entrepreneurs, CEOs, and other high-achievers, with around 70% female users and a focus on wealth and attractiveness. The average age is between 34 and 42, and it’s concentrated in major cities like LA and New York. If you’re looking for dating apps to meet rich guys and girls in NYC, you might want to check out Luxy
- EliteSingles: This app targets educated professionals, with over 80% holding a bachelor’s, master’s, or doctorate degree, and over 90% over 30 years old. It’s less about wealth and more about intellectual compatibility, with a user base that includes career-driven individuals seeking serious relationships. It has a global presence, with a significant portion in the U.S., Australia, and Canada, and around 5 million American members, with 900,000 active weekly
| Demographic | Luxy | EliteSingles |
| Income Focus | 41% earn $1M+, high-income | Not explicitly income-focused |
| Education Level | Not emphasized | 80%+ with bachelor’s or higher |
| Age Range | 34-42 average | Over 90% over 30 |
| Gender Split | ~70% female | Not specified, balanced assumed |
| Location | Major cities, limited elsewhere | Global, strong U.S. presence |
User reviews: What users say
A great way to determine whether a dating app will align with your dating goals and expectations is to see what other users are saying about it. Let’s find out:
- Luxy: Reviews are mixed across platforms. On the App Store, it scores 4.7/5, with users appreciating the exclusivity and quality of matches, like one reviewer noting, “All the men are so polite, no unsolicited pics here.” However, on SiteJabber (1.27/5) and Trustpilot (2.2/5), ratings are lower, with complaints about payment issues, limited local matches, and customer service. Some users feel it’s overpriced, with one saying, “Not worth the $300 I spent for 6 months,” while others love the high-end vibe. All in all, it’s definitely one of the most effecting dating site for attractive singles and affluent people looking for romantic connections, especially in major cities like New York
- EliteSingles: Also mixed, with 4+ stars on app stores but only 1 star on TrustPilot and SiteJabber. Users praise the focus on serious relationships and educated singles, with one saying, “I met a couple of very nice guys.” But there are complaints about the matchmaking algorithm, with many mentioning matches outside preferred locations, like, “I got matches hours away, even with a 50-mile limit.” Technical issues and account cancellation problems also pop up, with some feeling, “There wasn’t anything ‘elite’ about the users.”
| Platform | Luxy Rating | EliteSingles Rating |
| App Store | 4.7/5 | 4+/5 (varies) |
| SiteJabber | 1.27/5 | 1/5 |
| Trustpilot | 2.2/5 | 1/5 |
| Common Complaints | Payment issues, limited locals | Matches far away, technical glitches |
| Common Praises | Exclusivity, quality matches | Focus on serious relationships, educated users |
Both have their fans and detractors, but Luxy’s higher App Store rating suggests it’s more popular among the high-income dating sites, while EliteSingles’ criticisms highlight location and algorithm issues.
Related Reading: 19 Luxury Dates in NYC: Wine Tastings, Rooftop Bars & More
Customer support: Can you count on them for help?
Good customer support can make or break a user’s experience. Since both these high-end dating websites cost a pretty penny, a solid customer support framework is to be expected. But do the Luxy dating app and EliteSingles deliver on this expectation? Let’s find out:
- Luxy: Some users report dissatisfaction, with one mentioning, “After contacting support, the only instructions I got were to broaden my age range,” which didn’t address their issue with distant matches. Reviews suggest responses can be generic and unhelpful, especially for payment or location concerns
- EliteSingles: Generally, users have positive feedback, with one saying, “I emailed a question, and the customer care person got right back to me with the answer!” Another noted, “Truly excellent customer service. Thank you Elite!” It seems responsive and helpful, especially for resolving issues like fake profiles or billing.
| Aspect | Luxy | EliteSingles |
| Responsiveness | Mixed, some generic responses | Generally quick and helpful |
| User Feedback | Complaints about unhelpful replies | Praises for resolving issues |
| Contact Method | Email support mentioned | Email support, responsive |
Who it’s right for: Finding your fit
Even in the elite dating app space, not all options are created equal. What suits one person needs may not align with the other’s needs. So, is Luxy the right dating site for attractive singles? Is EliteSingles one of the dating apps to meet rich guys and girls? Let’s explore:
- Luxy: This is your app if you’re wealthy, successful, and attractive, looking to date within your socioeconomic circle. If you earn six figures or more and want someone who shares your luxury lifestyle, Luxy’s exclusivity and verification process are perfect. Since its user base is limited to major cities, It’s ideal for New York singles
- EliteSingles: If you’re an educated professional—think bachelor’s degree or higher, over 30, and career-driven—this app is for you. It’s great for those seeking serious, long-term relationships with someone who matches your intellectual capacity and career ambitions. It’s less about wealth and more about compatibility, with a global reach that might suit you if location isn’t a dealbreaker
| Criteria | Luxy | EliteSingles |
| Income Level | High, 41% earn $1M+ | Not income-focused |
| Education Level | Not emphasized | 80%+ with advanced degrees |
| Relationship Goal | Luxury lifestyle, exclusivity | Serious, long-term relationships |
| Location Preference | Best in major cities | Global, strong U.S. presence |
Luxy is for the luxury crowd; EliteSingles is for the career-focused intellectual. Choose based on what matters most to you.
Verdict: Which Delivers Real Matches?
So, which app delivers real matches? It depends on your priorities, but let’s break it down. If you’re specifically looking for matches among the wealthy and attractive, the Luxy dating app seems like a better choice. Its focus on exclusivity, with verified profiles and a vouching process, aims to provide a high-end dating experience.
Features like free messaging for matches and a sleek interface make it efficient for connecting with like-minded, high-value individuals. Sure, it can be pricey, and you might face challenges finding local matches outside major cities, but for its target audience—affluent singles—it’s worth the investment.
EliteSingles, on the other hand, is great for educated professionals seeking serious relationships. Its personality-driven matching and daily curated matches cater to those who value intellectual compatibility. However, user reviews highlight issues like distant matches and a less “elite” feel, which might frustrate you if location and exclusivity are key.
If you’re looking for a luxury dating experience, Luxy delivers. Its niche focus on wealth and attractiveness, combined with safety features like real-time verification, makes it stand out for those who fit its demographic. So, if you’re ready to elevate your dating game, why not give it a try? Sign up at Luxy and see if it clicks for you.